In the digital age, choosing between EverBank and SoFi can be a pivotal decision for everyday banking or high-yield savings. This comparison evaluates their APYs, fees, product offerings, user experience, and credibility to help you make a smarter choice for your finances.
1. Interest Rates & Product Variety (APY Focus)
- EverBank provides standout yields, including a 4.30% APY on Performance Savings accounts with no minimum balance and CDs up to 4.10% APYTrustpilotBankratetheadvisertimes.comForbes.
- SoFi offers decent APYs (e.g. ≈3.80% with recurring direct deposit) on checking and savings but does not offer CDs or money market accountsindexbox.ioCNN.
Verdict: If maximizing yield is your priority, especially via CDs, EverBank has the edge.
2. Fees, ATM Network & Overdrafts
- EverBank charges no monthly or overdraft fees, provides fee-free ATMs, and reimburses out-of-network fees (unlimited with $5K+ balance; up to $15 otherwise)Fox BusinessBankrate+1ConsumerAffairsForbes.
- SoFi also has no monthly maintenance fees, but its ATM (Allpoint) access is limited (~55,000 ATMs), and it does not reimburse out-of-network ATM feesForbes.
Verdict: EverBank wins on ATM coverage and reimbursements—SoFi is fee-light but more limited on ATM access.
3. Bonuses & Banking Features
- SoFi sweetens the deal with perks: $300 cash bonus for new accounts (with qualifying deposits), overdraft fee protection, and early paycheck accessindexbox.io.
- EverBank lacks promotional bonuses but offers CDARS for extended FDIC coverage, strong long-term interest, and bumped-rate CD optionsBankratetheadvisertimes.comForbes.
Verdict: For promotional extras and everyday convenience, SoFi shines. For long-term savings with insurance flexibility, EverBank scores.
4. Mobile Experience & Customer Support
- SoFi boasts a polished mobile app with budgeting tools, P2P transfers, expense trackers, and solid customer support via live chatForbes.
- EverBank is recognized for its robust digital platform, but its app and customer service draw mixed reviews—issues include withdrawal limits and inconsistent supportNerdWalletConsumerAffairsTrustpilotReddit+3Reddit+3Reddit+3.
- Reddit users report complaints like limited external transfer caps and downgraded interest rates for existing accountsReddit+1.
Verdict: SoFi offers more consistent user experience. EverBank may require extra patience.
5. Trustworthiness & Recognition
- EverBank has earned awards from Bankrate, Forbes Advisor, USA Today, Kiplinger, and GOBankingRates; holds a 5-star BauerFinancial rating; and boasts over $44B in assets and 85% FDIC-insured deposits as of mid-2025EverBank+1.
- SoFi transitioned to a national bank in 2022 and provides a diversified range of financial services—checking, savings, loans, credit cards, and moreindexbox.io.
Verdict: Both are reputable: EverBank excels in product stability and recognition; SoFi offers broader services under a modern fintech umbrella.
Final Recommendation
| Your Priority | Recommended Bank | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Highest savings / CD yield | EverBank | Superior APYs, CDs, CDARS coverage |
| Everyday banking convenience | SoFi | App usability, overdraft protection, early pay, bonus rewards |
| ATM coverage & fee reimbursements | EverBank | Larger ATM network and reimbursement structure |
| Best overall digital UX | SoFi | Polished app, tools, and consistent support |
| Long-term trust and financial strength | EverBank | Industry awards, strong capital base, FDIC strength |
everbank vs sofi, best online bank 2025, everbank review, sofi banking review, high yield savings comparison, everbank cd rates, sofi direct deposit bonus, online bank comparison, everbank fees vs sofi, sofi app review